Search is a big channel. There are die-hard people in the SEO world who never think about paid search as part of search…it’s advertising they say. There are PPC jockeys who have disdain for anything that doesn’t have an easy metric and a quick way to A-B test. Anything else is squishy, they say.
Well, any debate that pits natural search vs. paid search is missing the synergistic whole.
It’s all SEARCH.
Search is about the traffic that comes from results to specific queries. And while there is a difference between the way paid and natural search works, as a marketer, it may help you to think of them as a single channel, because they work together so well.
Imagine that your best paid keyword is dog bones and you pay $1.00 per click. And you drive some high quality traffic through paid search. And then you start to grow your presence in natural search. Let’s say you get dog bones into the top 10, and you start driving big traffic from that word. You might think about giving up your paid search budget for that word, because your natural search has started driving traffic at volume, and you have become overly efficient in your paid advertising for dog bones. You can no longer amp up the paid search volume by bidding more…so paid search can no longer put the pedal to the metal, as they say.
What has happened here? Has paid search lost it’s magic? NO WAY.
Let’s jump into some math – if you generate 5,000 clicks from dog bones via paid search per month, you are spending $5,000. If you are making a good ROI on that amount then great! But as your natural search visibility creeps up, you may find that it is only possible to spend $4500 at the same efficiency. Does this mean that that dog bones is no longer a good word? Absolutely not.
If you expand your focus and look at paid search and natural search together as a single channel, you might see a different story. Your TOTAL traffic from the word dog bones may have skyrocketed. Think of your 4,500 clicks from paid search in the context of the 5000 clicks that you are also getting from natural search. If you look at this as a whole channel, your average cost per click has just been more than halved (or your ROI has more than doubled). And if I use my fancy MBA calculator, I am pretty sure that either result is pretty great.
If we go back to your original budget of $5,000 for 5,000 clicks, and we look at your current situation of 9,500 clicks for $4,500, you will see that you are in a much better position with regard to the word dog bones. And you have at least $500 of budget that you can apply to testing new words, or amping up the volume on a word like dog bone holders where you don’t have premiere organic search visibility.
Search as a whole is a more powerful tool than looking at the natural and organic sides independently. Search is too big to be contained in silos. Let’s think that paid and natural search are different sales funnels, but they all point to the same cash register….yours.
Tim Kilroy is Vice President of Natural Search at PM Digital.
